Hesiod and the Whispers of the Muses

Delivered to Rabbi Ben Scolnic

Edited by Altay Coskun

March 2026

Late Roman Mosaic depicting Hesiod from the Mosel Valley, now Rheinisches Landesmuseum Trier.

 

A younger contemporary of Homer, Hesiod of Boeotian Ascra in central Greece wrote his partly autobiographical poetry around 700 BCE. His main works, the Theogonia (‘Birth of Gods’) and Erga kai hemerai (‘Works and Days’) reveal a more rigorous and systematic character than the Iliad and the Odyssey. While Homer dwells on grand narrative, tragic causation, and the allures of the exotic, Hesiod is taken in by what sustains life and holds human society together: on the one hand, the greatness of the divine in all its ramification, on the other hand, the detail of daily rural chores interwoven with the marvel of the regenerative force of nature. Hesiod may have followed in the footsteps of Homer as epic poet but created didactic literature in verse to educate the young and the common people at large. Yet he conveyed more than just factual information by instilling awe for the tangible nature and metaphysical forces in his audience. True enough, a pessimistic tone runs through his work, rooted in his personal experience of the harsh human condition and not rarely exacerbated by the cruelties inflicted by man on man. But this is balanced by his admiration of life and renewal, and by the divine as ultimate avenger of evil. It is this firm belief in divine justice that makes him akin to the Father of History Herodotus and to Biblical authors, and thus explains his appeal to Rabbi Ben. And so another series of dreams have been inspired by the Muses, the light-footed beauties dancing on Mount Helikon and turning Boeotia into another Tempe Valley, by breathing life into the verses Hesiod. And would you believe? They are still around chasing the echoes of the Ascraean poet in their cheerful dances, purring like breezes into Ben’s ears during his spring-time naps.

  • Ascra is a miserable village in winter, unbearable in summer, and seldom good at any time. My father fled here from Cyme across the dark sea, fleeing poverty, not realizing he was trading the terrifying whims of the sea for the equally terrifying whims of the local lords. When he died, he left what little he had scratched from this harsh Boeotian dirt to my brother, Perses, and me. I wanted only to divide it fairly, to take my plow to my half and let the seasons dictate my fortune. But Perses had the ear of the basileis—the bribe-swallowing lords who sit in the high seats and pass judgment over our lives. He slipped gifts into their greedy hands, and with a few crooked words, they gave him my livelihood.

    I watched them deliver their false verdicts, men draped in the trappings of authority, convinced that their word alone constituted the law. We men of the earth labor endlessly to build great stone walls around our cities, trusting in their sheer mass or perhaps the magic of their consecration to keep the enemy at bay. We think the danger always comes from the outside. But what good is a sacred, towering wall, what good are ramparts and watchtowers, when the rot is already inside the gates? A city that harbors crooked judges has already breached its own defenses from within.

    It was in the bitter cold of that loss that I understood a truth those lords will forever ignore: Justice—Dike—is not an invention of kings. It is not whatever the powerful decree it to be in the town square. It is the daughter of Zeus. When corrupt men drive her out with crooked judgments, she wraps herself in mist, walks through the streets weeping, and brings ruin upon the entire city. The crops fail, the women bear no children, and the great walls eventually crumble. The lords may feast today on the bribes they swallowed, but they are eating the seed corn of their own destruction. There is a divine, immovable order to the world that bends toward righteousness, not the whims of tyrants. I write my verses not merely to win back a patch of stolen dirt, but to warn them: the eye of Zeus sees everything, and he does not forgive those who mock his daughter.

  • When I was a younger, more foolish poet, I thought of Eris (‘Strife’) as a single, terrifying force. I sang of her only as the bloody-handed goddess who walks the battlefield, the one who drives men to slaughter each other over a barren strip of land or an imagined slight. I have heard the endless, grim tales of ancient warfare—of men freezing in squalid winter quarters, of grinding, years-long sieges designed to slowly starve a populace into submission, of kings taking the sons of their rivals as hostages to enforce a fragile, bitter peace. It is a terrible, consuming fire that leaves nothing but ash, orphans, and weeping widows. If that were the only Strife in the world, humanity would have been extinguished long ago by its own hand.

    But age, and a long life observing the mechanics of the world, have taught me to correct my own songs. I look around my village, and I see that there are actually two goddesses of Strife on this earth. The first is that cruel mother of war and sieges. But the second is older, born of the dark night, and Zeus placed her in the very roots of the earth to help us.

    This second Strife is the one that makes a man build a better, swifter ship because he sees his neighbor’s wealth growing. It is the fierce envy that drives the potter to shape a finer, more elegant vessel than the potter next door, or the builder to lay a straighter, stronger wall. This good Strife does not demand hostages or blood. She demands excellence. She stirs even the laziest, most shiftless man to work. When a man sees his neighbor rushing to plant his fields and order his house before the winter rains, he feels the sharp sting of that good Strife and reaches for his own plow. We must turn our backs entirely on the goddess of the battlefield. The true test of a man is not how long he can endure a winter siege to destroy another city, but how hard he is willing to strive to build his own.

  • I look at the men of my generation, and my heart is heavy with a sorrow that stretches back to the beginning of time. I wish to all the gods that I had died before this Age of Iron, or had been born long after it, for our time is one of unceasing labor, broken oaths, and profound grief. But to understand our current doom, you must understand the men who came before us, particularly the terrifying race of the men of Bronze.

    The Bronze men were a nightmare walking upon the earth, a heavy-handed race who sprang from ash trees and cared nothing for the plow, the harvest, or the quiet life of the hearth. Consumed by their love for the terrible groan of war and acts of unspeakable violence, they ate no bread and possessed hearts as hard and unforgiving as adamant and flint. Long before the advent of black iron, they forged everything—their heavy armor, their sprawling houses, and their lethal weapons—entirely of bronze. Believing their sheer martial power and mastery of weaponry made them invincible gods, they built massive armies to secure an eternal legacy, but their only reward for such terrible strength was their own undoing; they destroyed themselves with their own hands and passed into the dark, chilling house of Hades, leaving no name behind them.

    The gods did not need to hurl thunderbolts to destroy them. The Earth did not swallow them up. The Bronze men were destroyed entirely by their own hands. Their absolute obsession with warfare, their reliance on the sword and the spear to solve every grievance, was a poison they brewed and drank themselves. They slaughtered each other into absolute extinction, passing down into the dark, lightless house of Hades and leaving no names behind.

    For Hesiod’s fuller view on the succession of ages, read his Works and Days, 109–201.

  • You ask why we must remember this. You ask why we must recite the long, wearying lines of fathers and sons, of mothers and monsters, back to the very dawn of creation. It is because blood is the memory of the Earth, and to know a thing’s birth is to know its inescapable nature. You cannot grasp the bitter fruit of our current doom without first tracing the twisted roots from which the tree of man has grown.

    Genealogy is not the idle boasting of kings; it is the absolute architecture of the cosmos. When the Muses, the daughters of Memory, breathed their divine voice into me upon the slopes of Mount Helicon, they did not sing of fleeting things. They sang of what was, and what is, and what is to come—and all of it is bound by the unbreakable chain of birth.

    Through lineage, we understand the architecture of divine justice. Even wide-seeing Zeus holds his thunderous throne by right of succession and the overthrow of his father, Cronus, who in turn struck down his own father, starry Ouranus. The universe is governed by inheritance.

    And look to the dark progeny that plagues us now! We must know that black Night gave birth to Doom, and to pitiless Death, and to hard-hearted Strife. And what did Strife bear? She gave birth to Toil, Forgetfulness, Famine, and tearful Sorrows. These are the relentless companions of our Iron generation. We suffer not by accident, but because we are forced to walk alongside these ancient, dark children of the cosmos. They are our cousins in the fabric of creation.

    By remembering the generations, we measure the length of our fall. We remember the Golden race who lived like gods without sorrow, and the Silver race who lacked the wits to revere the immortals. We remember the brief, glorious interruption of the Heroic race, the demigods who fought at Troy and Thebes, whose blood was a final, flickering ember of nobility before the gods gave us over to this wretched age.

  • Now, we are the men of Iron. We mix our daily misery with wickedness. Might makes right in our streets, guests turn on their hosts, and reverence for the gods is fading into memory. I fear we are walking the exact, blood-soaked path of the Bronze men. When a society structures its entire existence around the capacity for violence, when it praises the warrior above the farmer and the judge, it is simply building its own funeral pyre. The Bronze men show us the inevitable trajectory of violence: it does not lead to eternal glory. It leads only to mutually assured destruction—to the dark, silent earth, where all our grand weapons rust uselessly beside our bones.

    And what halts our descent into that dark earth? Nothing. For the final, most terrible omen is already upon us.

    I see them wrapping their beautiful, shining white robes about their immortal shoulders. Aidos and Nemesis are leaving us. They are abandoning the blood-stained dust of the earth to join the deathless gods on Olympus, and with them goes the very soul of our humanity.

    Mourn for Aidos! She was the blush of shame on the cheek of the wrongdoer, the quiet reverence we once held for the old, the sacred, and the vulnerable. She was the invisible boundary that kept men from becoming beasts. Without her, there is no hesitation before the strike, no guilt after the theft. The wicked man will speak with a smooth tongue and a black heart, and he will feel nothing.

    And weep for Nemesis! The soft-spoken philosophers of tomorrow might try to lessen her, calling her mere 'Indignation'—a fleeting, helpless anger at the sight of injustice. Fools. They do not know what we are losing. She is not merely the offended gasp of the righteous; she is the Avenger. She is the cosmic counterweight, the divine consequence that shatters hubris and snaps the scales of justice back into balance. When a man grew too proud, too violent, too greedy, it was the Avenger who brought the hammer down upon his house.

    But no longer. By leaving us, Nemesis takes consequence with her. The wicked will flourish without fear of retribution. The good will suffer without hope of vindication.

    Left behind is only bitter sorrow for mortal men. We are stripped of our protectors, entirely defenseless against the encroaching evil. The iron in our hearts has driven away the last of the divine light, and we are left alone in the dark to devour ourselves.

  • My brother Perses, like so many fools in this world, believes that wealth and comfort should come easily. He looks at the lords in their fine woolen cloaks, spending their days lingering in the agora, listening to lawsuits and trading idle gossip, and he deeply envies their idleness. He thinks that sweat is a curse, that dirt under the fingernails is a mark of the lowly, and that true success means escaping work altogether. I have spent my life trying to beat this foolishness out of his head with my words.

    Work is no disgrace; it is idleness that is the true, rotting shame of a man's soul. The gods have ordained that the road to excellence—arete—is incredibly steep, long, and covered in sweat. You do not find virtue standing in the town square, shouting over petty disputes. You find it long before dawn, when the air is biting cold, yoking the heavy oxen and cutting the first difficult furrow into the dark, resisting earth. You find it in the relentless, rhythmic obedience to the seasons: pruning the vines precisely when the swallow returns, and harvesting the grain the moment the Pleiades rise in the sky.

    There is a quiet, profound, and sacred dignity in this daily maintenance of human life. The men who grow the grain, who build the sturdy wagons, who shear the sheep in the spring—we are the ones who hold the world together. We keep society from collapsing into starvation and chaos. The idle lords may wear the crowns and hand down the judgments, but it is the calloused hand of the laborer that sustains the very breath of the city. To work the earth is to enter into a holy rhythm with the cosmos. It is the only honest way to fill your barns and keep the grim, skeletal specter of famine from peering through your window. Let Perses have his crooked lawsuits and his idle dreams. I will take my plow, for it is the only tool that yields true, lasting, and honorable wealth.

  • Why must we labor so brutally just to survive? Why does the earth not simply bring forth grain on its own, as the old tales say it did during the Golden Age? The answer lies in the ancient anger of Zeus. The gods have deliberately hidden the easy means of life from humanity, burying our sustenance deep in the soil and tying it to the cruel turning of the seasons.

    It began with Prometheus, who thought he could outsmart the king of the gods. He stole the fire and brought it to us, thinking he was giving humanity total dominion over the world, freeing us from the dark and the cold. But Zeus is not mocked, and nature cannot be cheated. In return for the stolen fire, he gave us a beautiful, terrible gift: Pandora, and with her, he unleashed toil, sickness, and exhausting, unending labor upon the earth. The easy life was locked away forever.

    This is the harsh ecological reality we must accept: the earth is not an endless, overflowing horn of plenty. It is stubborn, it is profoundly finite, and it requires our blood and sweat to yield its fruits. The spring rains may fail; the brutal summer heat may scorch the vines before they ripen; the bitter month of Lenaion may drag on until the barley runs out and the cattle starve. We are always, in every generation, just one bad harvest away from absolute ruin.

    Therefore, a man must be fiercely practical. He must gather his resources carefully, wasting nothing. He must not presume that tomorrow will be bountiful just because today is comfortable. We are bound by the absolute limits of the natural world, and any man who thinks he can cheat the soil, exhaust his fields, or ignore the changing of the constellations is a fool inviting starvation into his home. We live in a world of strict scarcity, and our only defense against it is tireless work, careful preservation of what we have, and a deep, fearful reverence for the boundaries the gods have drawn around us.

The Dance of the Muses at Mount Helicon by Bertel Thorvaldsen (1807). Alte Nationalgalerie, Berlin.